Hidden chambers, a sinister hotel and hundreds of victims: the popular H. H. Holmes story reads like a horror film. Historical research gives good reasons to question that version.
Holmes, born Herman Webster Mudgett, was a fraudster and murderer. But the familiar claim that he killed 200 people in a Chicago “murder castle” is not an established victim count.
Historian Adam Selzer, interviewed by HISTORY, places the number of people Holmes probably killed at about nine. That estimate is itself different from a list of murder convictions. Holmes’s confession to 27 killings was unreliable: some people he named were still alive.
The building’s lower floors contained shops and rental accommodation. Selzer says the proposed hotel floor was never opened to the public. Sensational newspaper coverage helped transform the building into a legendary killing machine.
The investigation ultimately connected Holmes to the murder of his associate Benjamin Pitezel and the deaths of three of Pitezel’s children. Holmes was executed in Philadelphia in May 1896.
Questioning exaggerated stories does not diminish those deaths. It restores attention to the people harmed and reminds readers that a gripping detail still needs evidence.
Sources:
HISTORY, “Did Serial Killer H.H. Holmes Really Build a ‘Murder Castle’?”
https://www.history.com/articles/murder-castle-h-h-holmes-chicago
Smithsonian Magazine, “The Enduring Mystery of H.H. Holmes, America’s ‘First’ Serial Killer”
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/enduring-mystery-hh-holmes-americas-first-serial-killer-180977646/
H. H. Holmes. Unknown photographer; public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Image source.
More From This Category
View all True Crime →
Russell Brand in custody: what is known about his first days behind bars

The Mona Lisa theft of 1911: the attempted sale that brought the painting back

The recovered Cooper ransom money answers one question and leaves others open

The Lindbergh ransom money shows why a trail of records matters

Alcatraz: why the FBI closing its escape file did not solve the mystery

BTK Killer Dennis Rader: The Crimes, the Victims and the Floppy Disk That Exposed Him
Other Articles You May Like

On Venus, “a day” needs a more careful definition

The Picnic at Hanging Rock outtakes show why archives keep more than the finished film

Amazon low-inventory-level fee explained—and how to avoid it

SSD and hard drive: the difference starts with what has to move

Chrome IP Protection is ending — what changes and what to use instead


